Finger Lakes Legend Grabowski Finds Diamond in the Rough With Kentucky Oaks Hopeful Dotsy
Finger Lakes Legend Grabowski Finds Diamond in the Rough With Kentucky Oaks Hopeful Dotsy
The LifeIn a sport synonymous with names like Calumet and Whitney, there is a reason that stories like Seabiscuit and Mine That Bird resonate with fans: we root for the little guy, the underdog, those who simply need the opportunity to show that greatness can come from anywhere.
A journeyman jockey turned trainer, John Grabowski found a diamond in the rough in a filly named Dotsy and parlayed decades of experience into a Grade 1 victory that highlights just what the little guy can do.
Grabowski has seen the sport at all levels. The California native’s connection to racing started with family: his uncle Bill Strange is a member of Finger Lakes’ Hall of Fame, and his step-grandfather and stepfather, Harold and Charles Wright, had a cattle ranch where horses were an integral part of his youth. “I grew up on horseback, basically,” the trainer remembered.
A stint starting young horses for Harris Farms in Coalinga, Calif., led to joining his uncle’s barn at Finger Lakes, where he rounded out his education in the saddle before striking out on his own as a jockey.

In addition to riding at Florida Downs (now Tampa Bay Downs), Grabowski rode at Turf Paradise near Phoenix, Ariz., and Hollywood Park in California. “I pretty much started my apprenticeship out there in California at Hollywood Park. The jockey colony was very fierce out there,” Grabowski recalled.
“You had [Bill] Shoemaker, Chris McCarron, Eddie Delahoussaye, Laffit Pincay. Those are the riders that actually kind of helped polish me up for my journeyman years.”
He eventually settled down in Farmington, N.Y., where he dominated the Finger Lakes riding ranks for nearly three decades. When Grabowski retired in 2011, he had amassed 3,401 wins in 17,614 starts with $28,185,106 in purse earnings. He was the track’s second-leading all-time jockey with 77 stakes wins and six leading rider titles. The following year, he hung up his shingle as a trainer, with wife, Pauline, at his side. Since then, the former jockey, who still occasionally gets on horses, has focused on preparing horses for the races, a contrast to his former job as pilot.
“[Training] is probably the hardest thing I’ve ever done. I would’ve thought riding races and just the grind with riding every day, I didn’t think anything could be any harder than that. Training a horse is a lot harder, really, just mentally, physically, everything. It takes so much of your time,” Grabowski explained.

“When you win races, it is so rewarding because you put so much into it. And then when you see results, there’s nothing better.”
Much of his business as a trainer has focused on claimers, but one of his owners, Thomas Paluck, who races as TSP Enterprises, wanted to focus on young horses instead. That shift had Grabowski reaching out to Josie Palmisano, a friend and former assistant to trainer Linda Rice, who put together a short list of yearlings for the 2025 Fasig-Tipton Kentucky October yearling sale.
“I think there were probably 30 horses on the list on that day that I’d looked at,” Grabowski said. “And then I saw [Dotsy], and I fell in love with her when I saw her.”
Included on that list was a filly by 2019 Wood Memorial Stakes winner Tacitus, runner-up in that year’s Belmont and Travers Stakes, out of the Fusaichi Pegasus mare Coqui. Bred by Drs. Scott and Deborah Spike-Pierce, who also bred 2022 Dubai World Cup winner Country Grammer, the gray gal caught the trainer’s eye straightaway.
“She was beautiful. She was very correct. She already looked like she was a 2-year-old at the time,” he remembered. “She was just very well put together. She covered all the bases that I wanted in a yearling.”
Grabowski purchased her for Paluck for $37,000, a reasonable price he attributes to her being cataloged for the final day of the sale as well as Coqui’s produce record: the unraced mare has produced nine starters from 11 foals, with Dirt Monster, a stakes winner at Zia Park and Sunland Park, coming early in her breeding career and her lone stakes winner at the time of the auction. But the steel gray filly showed that her dam was not quite done producing good racehorses.
“When I started training her, she was so impressive with all of her workouts. We were breezing her against some pretty decent horses, and she was doing it so easily, defeating them all,” the trainer said.
“I’m sure a lot of people went back and said, ‘Well, how did I miss this one?’ ”
Named Dotsy after Paluck’s wife, Dorothy, the Tacitus filly has impressed her trainer with her quality and has become a favorite in the Grabowski barn.
“She’s a really loving individual. She loves attention. But when you get on her, she’s got a mind of her own. If she wants to stop, she’ll just stop, and you kind of just have to let her do her own thing,” he said.
From the word go, Dotsy proved a different kind of horse than what the former jockey typically had in his barn, blowing away solid horses with ease in the mornings. Understanding her potential, he opted to send her 200 miles down the road to Saratoga Race Course to make her debut. But prior to her first race, the filly ran into a hiccup.
“I had to scratch her because she was really naughty in the paddock the day before. We took her in the stall to practice saddling her, to school her. As soon as I got to tacking on, I cinched her up, and she went over backward and she got stuck on the wall,” Grabowski recalled.
“You can’t even imagine what was going through my brain at the time. You go from knowing you have a really good horse to really being worried if she is going to be OK off of this? But she got up and she was fine.”

Though she was physically unhurt, Dotsy needed more schooling from her trainer to make sure that she was mentally ready for her debut, which came nearly three weeks later on Aug. 26. With Kendrick Carmouche in the saddle, the Tacitus filly broke a step slow and raced greenly on the backstretch, Carmouche keeping her to the outside of the field. Around the turn, she settled down and found her lane, quickly putting the competition away to win by four lengths. But the timing left Grabowski with a problem: there was not another race with the right conditions he could enter her in until November, except for the Grade 1 Frizette Stakes, a one-mile test for 2-year-old fillies at Belmont Park in early October.
“I almost didn’t enter her in it. I didn’t really want that path for her,” Grabowski said. “Coming off that maiden special weight race at Saratoga, there were no other races anywhere at the time. I just wanted to run her in an allowance race just to get her a steppingstone.”
He nominated her for the Frizette but stopped short of officially entering her until he learned that the field was going to be short, with six already entered. After a conversation with Paluck, they paid the $3,700 entry fee and prepared to ship her to Belmont for her second start, her first start in stakes company.
“After looking at the field, I said, ‘There’s a couple of really tough horses, but she really does fit in there.’ At least I thought she did,” Grabowski said.
But the filly was dealing with a cold at the time, and the trainer stopped short of saying they were definitely a go until right before he shipped her. When she showed no sign of mucus a week before the Frizette, Dotsy made the trip downstate to the new Belmont Park for the biggest race of Grabowski’s career.
“She had a really good post at the time, too. She got the five hole. She broke really good, and she was really tugging on Kendrick. I’m going, ‘Wow, she’s going to run really good,’ ” the trainer recalled. “She inherited the lead, and it was like the same race that she ran in Saratoga. I felt very confident, and of course, I was screaming at the time, ‘Go, Dotsy! Come on, Dotsy!’ ”
In a race that featured horses from the barns of classic-winning trainers like Chad Brown, Jena Antonucci, and Kelly Breen as well as top trainers like Mark Hennig and George Weaver, Dotsy tracked the leaders in third and then took over in the stretch, winning by 2 3/4 lengths. Not only was it Grabowski’s first graded stakes win as a trainer, but it was also his first graded stakes win ever. He had not won one in his decades as a jockey.
“It was the most unbelievable feeling when she crossed the finish line. I can’t explain the happiness and the relief and the joy, all the emotion that was going through my brain at the time, because it was such a fulfillment that I never got. As a rider, you don’t get that one-on-one experience with your horses. As a trainer, you do. They’re like your kids.”
With the Frizette behind them, a stop in Lexington for the 2026 Breeders’ Cup at Keeneland was next, but Grabowski scratched Dotsy from the Juvenile Fillies a week before the race. He did not like how she came out of a half-mile workout Oct. 21 and decided against trying the 1 1/16-mile test.
“She’d been in training since this time last year, and she’d been going straight since she came into us at Finger Lakes. Training 2-year-olds, it takes longer to get them ready. You have to put them through a lot. Every horse needs a little bit of rest now and then,” he said.
In the meantime, Grabowski is still basking in the glow of what his Tacitus filly has accomplished, not only for the team behind her but for smaller barns like his.
“Her win, really, it wasn’t just for me. It was for all the other small trainers out there in this country that work so hard seven days a week and keep going,” he said.
“It’s funny how you just always dream of getting your next big horse, how that keeps us going. This is for all those trainers that struggle, because in this day and age smaller trainers, they’re getting fewer and fewer.”
Now the Palucks and Grabowski have a new target in their sights: the 2027 Longines Kentucky Oaks. As Dotsy enjoys time off to mature into a 3-year-old, her team is looking to bring her back either at Belmont or in Florida. From there, “she’s going to have to determine that path. There are a lot of different races we could try.”
Thanks to his relationship with Paluck, Grabowski knows that he has the support he needs as they prepare Dotsy for 2027.
“I feel very confident because my owner gives me confidence. He leaves everything up to me. He’s let me make all decisions, and that makes it easy to do what you need to do. I know what to do with her to get her prepared,” Grabowski said. “She’s going to tell me what she can do going forward. She really, truly is an incredible talent.”
As they look toward their next adventure, the road to Louisville and the April 30 Oaks, Grabowski is philosophical about this new challenge. Chasing lilies may be higher stakes than going for that first win, but in the end, the job is the same.
“It’s different, but you’re still training horses. It’s still the same thing that we’ve been doing. It’s just I haven’t had a horse to train like this, but she’s still a horse.”