Byron King’s Derby Dozen for May 1

RacingContent provided by BloodHorse
Byron King Derby Dozen BloodHorse Kentucky Derby Just Steel Domestic Product Honor Marie Stronghold Dornoch Forever Young Mystik Dan Catching Freedom Just a Touch Sierra Leone Fierceness Resilience horse racing
Horses train on the morning of April 29 at Churchill Downs at the start of Kentucky Derby week 2024. (Eclipse Sportswire)

BloodHorse news editor Byron King presents his final Derby Dozen with a look at his leading contenders for the Kentucky Derby Presented by Woodford Reserve on May 4.

Post positions were drawn for the 150th Kentucky Derby on April 27, and now the contenders are conducting their final gallops over Churchill Downs’ main track in preparation for the Derby, which has a scheduled post time of 6:57 p.m. ET Saturday. The race will be broadcast live on NBC and streamed on Peacock.

Check out America’s Best Racing’s Triple Crown page to keep up to date with stories and statistics on the Road to the Kentucky Derby.


Eclipse Sportswire

1. Fierceness

Dominant in winning the Curlin Florida Derby Presented by Hill ‘n’ Dale Farms at Xalapa by a record-setting 13 ½ lengths, last year’s 2-year-old champion has maintained his edge in subsequent training, first at Palm Beach Downs and most recently at Churchill Downs, suggesting he may be able to avoid the bounce that hindered him following blowout wins. In his final breeze before the Derby, a half-mile April in :48.80, he galloped out faster than most horses work. Clockers caught his next two eighths in :12 apiece under three-time Kentucky Derby winner John Velazquez. If he can avoid adversity in Saturday’s race, the Derby is his for the taking.


Eclipse Sportswire

2. Sierra Leone

Were it not for the brilliance of Fierceness, the buzz would be all about this colt leading up to the May 4 run for the roses. A $2.3 million purchase, he has met the high expectations that have surrounded him since his acquisition as a yearling. The addition of blinkers this year has resulted in improved focus and development, resulting in victories in the Risen Star Stakes and Toyota Blue Grass Stakes, quite possibly the two best preps on the Kentucky Derby trail this year, at least top to bottom. He sits behind Fierceness due to lacking speed. Traffic or ground loss could impede his chances as a deep closer in a field of 20 horses.


Eclipse Sportswire

3. Catching Freedom

Though he was outworked in his final Derby tuneup by Stonestreet Lexington Stakes winner Encino – an early scratch from the Kentucky Derby – it is important to bear in mind that Catching Freedom is a colt that shines in the afternoons, not the mornings. He has stepped up his game from a training perspective, but others are better in practice than him. But he puts on his game face when it is race day. Though the pace of the 1 3/16-mile Twinspires.com Louisiana Derby was slow, he still managed to rally to victory, boding well for his chances over 1 ¼ miles in the Derby.


Eclipse Sportswire

4. Mystik Dan

If it rains on Derby Day, creating an off track, his chances improve. He won the Southwest Stakes by eight lengths in the mud this year before running a still-good third on a fast track in the Arkansas Derby when hung wide. Drawn in post 3, he should be able to follow the rail-drawn Dornoch and jump ahead of deep-closing Sierra Leone in post 2, giving jockey Brian Hernandez Jr. a chance to save ground on Mystik Dan. Hernandez “knows the rail here about as good as anybody but (three-time Derby-winning jockey) Calvin Borel, and he’s not playing,” trainer Kenny McPeek said.


Eclipse Sportswire

5. Just a Touch 

With only three starts, he’s light on experience but he has considerable upside for trainer Brad Cox. The Blue Grass runner-up is blessed with speed, and if he can improve upon his first route when second to Sierra Leone, he could threaten in the Derby. He made a favorable impression with a spirited gallop April 30 at Churchill Downs, which followed sharp breezes leading up to the race.


Eclipse Sportswire

6. Forever Young

Japanese and American horses are trained differently, making direct comparisons of workouts challenging. Quite often, Japanese horses will breeze a longer distance at a slow pace before quickening over the closing few furlongs. Even with that under consideration, this 5-for-5 Japanese horse dips a few spots in the rankings due to underwhelming gallops and breezes leading up to the Derby. His connections acknowledged he was a little flat after traveling to America from the Middle East, where he won the Saudi Derby and UAE Derby Sponsored by Atlantis The Royal, before showing renewed enthusiasm of late at Churchill Downs.


Eclipse Sportswire

7. Resilience

Though his speed figures are soft, and he is coming off a victory in one of the weaker final preps, the Wood Memorial Stakes Presented by Resorts World Casino, he has kept good company overall. When a maiden through his 2-year-old season, he raced against eventual stakes winners Locked, Stronghold, and Track Phantom, and this year he was fourth in an ultra-key Risen Star, beaten only 3 ½ lengths by Sierra Leone. If he improved upon that effort, as it appeared he did when racing with blinkers in the Wood, he is not far away from threatening in the Derby.


Eclipse Sportswire

8. Dornoch 

A mediocre Blue Grass performance in which he ran fourth coupled with an unfavorable draw in the Derby, in which he starts from the inside post, leaves him in the bottom half of the Dozen rankings. Though the inside post in the continuous gate leaves him about 12 feet farther out than during the old days of the two-gate system, being drawn in post 1 in a massive field would appear a hindrance as it leaves jockey Luis Saez little choice but to send him early. The colt did not react well when rated in fourth inside in the Blue Grass before he was angled out for an even finish.


Eclipse Sportswire

9. Stronghold

Not many stakes races produce three Kentucky Derby starters, and yet the maiden race he won at Churchill Downs last fall has done just that. In addition to Stronghold, runner-up Resilience  and third-place Track Phantom are in Saturday’s first leg of the Triple Crown. Since that maiden win in October, Stronghold has been either first or second in four follow-up stakes starts. Having shown an affinity for Churchill Downs, he should run to his potential in the Derby. Others just might be faster.


Eclipse Sportswire

10. Honor Marie 

Though his bullet five-furlong breeze in :59.20 April 25 at Churchill Downs was one of the best of his career, his subsequent gallops and day-to-day training have not been on the same level as some of the key Derby contenders. Others are larger than him, and he carries his head a bit awkwardly. He gives the appearance of being the equine version of a basketball player with less-than-perfect shooting form who can still put the ball in the bucket. The Louisiana Derby runner-up has a bit of a home-track edge, having already won twice at Churchill Downs, including in the Kentucky Jockey Club Stakes last fall.


Coady Media

11. Domestic Product

Stepping up into Grade 1 company after winning the Lambholm South Tampa Bay Derby almost two months ago, he is a class question mark. He is also questionable as a top prospect in terms of speed figures, though slow-paced races this year have likely limited his ability to run quickly. His primary appeal is how he has trained leading up to the race, moving nicely in company with Sierra Leone in a joint breeze over the Churchill Downs main track April 27.


Eclipse Sportswire

12. Just Steel 

His Arkansas Derby was encouraging – a two-length defeat when second to the Bob Baffert-trained Muth, who likely would have been the third or fourth favorite in this race had he been eligible to compete. (Muth runs next in the Preakness Stakes owing to Churchill Downs Inc.’s ban of trainer Baffert from competing at its tracks.) So this colt’s competitive effort – being wide, no less – offers hope. Supporters have to be willing to accept Just Steel’s ordinary 2-for-11 career record and 0-for-4 mark at age 3, however.

newsletter sign-up

Stay up-to-date with the best from America's Best Racing!

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Instagram TikTok YouTube
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Instagram TikTok YouTube