Three Budgets, Three Preakness Stakes Wagering Strategies

Gambling
Fans at Pimlico cheer home a winner in this file photo from 2017 Preakness weekend. (Penelope P. Miller/America's Best Racing)

Historically speaking, it has been difficult for “new shooters” to prevail in the $1.5 million, Grade 1 Preakness Stakes at Pimlico Race Course, the second leg of the Triple Crown.

The statistics are daunting. Horses coming out of the Kentucky Derby have long dominated the Preakness, winning 31 of the last 35 renewals, while runners who skipped the Derby for one reason or another—the “new shooters”—have struggled to reach the Preakness winner’s circle.

But could 2019 be an exception to the overall trend? It’s possible. The first four horses to cross the finish line in the Derby are all skipping the Preakness, leaving a less-imposing group of four also-rans to represent the Derby at Pimlico. And when they line up in the Preakness starting gate, they’ll be significantly outnumbered by a better-than-usual group of nine newcomers eager for a chance to shine on one of racing’s biggest stages.

One of the new shooters is Anothertwistafate (#12), who just failed to qualify for the Kentucky Derby presented by Woodford Reserve after enduring troubled trips in the Grade 3 Sunland Park Derby and the Grade 3 Stonestreet Lexington Stakes. In both races, Anothertwistafate had to wait behind horses at key points on the far turn, allowing the eventual winners to sweep by unimpeded on the outside. Even worse, he spent almost the entirety of the Lexington Stakes racing along a slow rail, which further compromised his chances.

To Anothertwistafate’s credit, he managed to rally and finish second on both occasions. I’m excited to see him draw an outside post position in the Preakness, because I think he’s much more effective when allowed to race in the clear. This colt has a powerful stride and runs straight and true through the homestretch, which has allowed him to post fast-finishing fractions even in defeat. The last time he got a clear run, he dominated the El Camino Real Derby in front-running fashion, defeating Bob Baffert’s next-out stakes winner Kingly by seven lengths.

In terms of Beyer Speed Figures, Anothertwistafate has been posting consistent numbers in the 94-95 range, placing him among the fastest horses in the Preakness field. The only horse who has run consistently faster is morning-line favorite Improbable (#4), but if Anothertwistafate takes a step forward with a clean trip, he can make up the difference.

Anothertwistafate is 6-1 on the morning line and I’m enthusiastic about betting him to win at that price, though I’m also planning to play him in exotic bets like the exacta and trifecta. The above-mentioned Improbable — the only Grade 1 winner in the field — is a logical candidate to include in the exotics since he crossed the finish line fifth in the Kentucky Derby, a race in which he spent most of his journey boxed in behind horses. Improbable could be in for a similar trip while breaking from post-position four in the Preakness, but perhaps Hall of Fame jockey Mike Smith — riding Improbable for the first time — can secure a better trip.

Bourbon War (#2) was compromised by a slow pace when finishing fourth in the Grade 1 Xpressbet Florida Derby behind Maximum Security, Bodexpress, and Code of Honor. He’ll add blinkers in an effort to stay a little closer to the lead in the Preakness, but an honest pace could be the true key to a turnaround for this son of Tapit, who finished a close second in the Grade 2 Xpressbet Fountain of Youth Stakes two starts back.

An intriguing longshot contender is Warrior’s Charge (#3), who has really upped his game in recent months for increasingly high-profile trainer Brad Cox. He’s dominated his last two starts at Oaklawn Park in front-running fashion, winning by an average margin of 6 ¼ lengths while posting increasing Beyer Speed Figures of 89 and 97. He’ll be involved in the pace from the outset and could be surprisingly dangerous — he’s won with such ease that we really don’t have any idea how good he might be.

Depending on the size of your betting budget, I have three different wagering strategies for you to consider. The plays involving exactas and trifectas are more expensive, but they also offer greater potential for a truly impressive payoff.

Wagering Strategy on a $10 Budget: Win Bet

$10 to win on #12 Anothertwistafate

Wagering Strategy on a $20 Budget: Exactas

$3 exacta: 12 with 2,3,4 ($9)

$5 exacta: 4 with 12 ($5)

$3 exacta: 2,3 with 12 ($6)

Wagering Strategy on a $30 Budget: Trifectas

$1 trifecta: 12 with 2,3,4 with 1,2,3,4,5 ($12)

$1 trifecta: 2,3,4 with 12 with 1,2,3,4,5 ($12)

$1 trifecta: 4,12 with 4,12 with 2,3 ($4)

$0.50 trifecta: 4,12 with 4,12 with 1,5 ($2)

Good luck, and enjoy the race!

2019 Preakness S.
May 18th, 2019

Winning Time: 1:54.34
  • Purse: $1,500,000
  • Distance: 1 3/16 Miles
  • Age: 3 yo
  • Surface: Dirt
  • Winning Time: 1:54.34
Results
Win
Place
Show
1st
1 War of Will
$14.20
$7.40
$5.40
  • Owner / Gary Barber
  • Breeder / Flaxman Holdings Limited
2nd
10 Everfast
$32.00
$14.40
3rd
5 Owendale
$6.00
  • Owner / Rupp Racing
  • Breeder / Stonestreet Thoroughbred Holdings, LLC
4th
3 Warrior's Charge
5th
11 Laughing Fox
6th
4 Improbable
7th
13 Win Win Win
8th
2 Bourbon War
10th
12 Anothertwistafate
11th
7 Alwaysmining
12th
6 Market King
13th
9 Bodexpress
Payoff
Pick 3
1-1/6/12-1
1-1/6/12-1
$256
Pick 4
4/6-1-1/6/12-1
4/6-1-1/6/12-1
$1,041
Pick 5
9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
$7,353
Pick 6 Jackpot
1/8-9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
1/8-9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
$8,623
Daily Double
BES-PREAK 8-1
BES-PREAK 8-1
$47
Daily Double
12-1
12-1
$19
Exacta
1-10
1-10
$474
Superfecta
1-10-5-3
1-10-5-3
$51,924
Super High Five
1-10-5-3-11
1-10-5-3-11
$0
Trifecta
1-10-5
1-10-5
$4,700
Race Replay
Play
Payoff
Pick 3
1-1/6/12-1
1-1/6/12-1
$256
Pick 4
4/6-1-1/6/12-1
4/6-1-1/6/12-1
$1,041
Pick 5
9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
$7,353
Pick 6 Jackpot
1/8-9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
1/8-9-4/6-1-1/6/12-1
$8,623
Daily Double
BES-PREAK 8-1
BES-PREAK 8-1
$47
Daily Double
12-1
12-1
$19
Exacta
1-10
1-10
$474
Superfecta
1-10-5-3
1-10-5-3
$51,924
Super High Five
1-10-5-3-11
1-10-5-3-11
$0
Trifecta
1-10-5
1-10-5
$4,700

newsletter sign-up

Stay up-to-date with the best from America's Best Racing!